Communications
club_cafe
HelpRegister
Fees
Thank you, I ran the reports and it does group a few
together, but I basically had to go through and add them all
up. Is there a different heading I could list the fees under
so they show up on Bivio? Like Misc Income, I assume we
could then be taxed on this.

MJ HARNEY wrote:
> Please remove my name
> Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: John W Ranby <coljake@bivio.com>
> Date: Fri, 25 Feb 2011 18:29:38
> To: <club_cafe@bivio.com>
> Subject: club_cafe: Re: Fees
>
> Kevin Valade wrote:
> > Hello all,
> >
> > I am trying to get a report in Bivio of "late" fees, which
> > have always been entered as fees. The club then uses this
> > money to pay for misc expenses or club subscriptions ect. Is
> > there anywhere I can get a total for the last 3 years? I
> > looked under reports and did not really see anything. Thank
> > you for your help.
>
> Kevin:
>
> The direct answer to your questions is "No, there is not a
> canned report that will  list only the transactions entered
> as "fees" for a period that spans several calendar years.
> However, there are tools that will provide you with the
> information you seek.
>
> I want to avoid a discussion regarding the appropriateness
> of "fees"; however, it is important to understand that there
> is no accounting connection between the source of the funds
> paying an expense and the expense itself. There is no
> accounting or tax relationship between the expense and
> whether the source of the funds to pay the expense is member
> payments, fees, dividends, interest, or capital gains. Your
> club's practice should only be thought of as a budgeting
> tool.
>
> Full disclosure: my club never has fees so I don't have
> practical experience with them in bivio. However, I did
> enter several transactions in the demo club involving fees
> and discovered the following:
>
> 1. Multiple fees entered on the same day are consolidated
> and show up as a single entry in the "transaction" report.
> 2. Fee transactions for different dates in the same calendar
> year are all listed together in the "transaction" report for
> that calendar year.
>
> 3. So you could run a transaction report for each calendar
> year and find the "fee" transactions that way.
>
> 4. If you have a lot of fee entries, you could then export
> the data to a spreadsheet and further manipulate the data as
> you want.
>
> Hope that helps.
>
> Jack Ranby, Treasurer
> Grants Partners Investment Club
On Sun, Feb 27, 2011 at 2:56 PM, Kevin Valade <kade4111@bivio.com> wrote:
Thank you, I ran the reports and it does group a few
together, but I basically had to go through and add them all
up. Is there a different heading I could list the fees under
so they show up on Bivio? Like Misc Income, I assume we
could then be taxed on this.

Dear Kevin,

The bivio reports show the way different things are accounted for. Fees are a type of member contribution. Many think a better name for them is Penalties because they do not affect the contributing members ownership share, they increase the value of each club members account.

You are correct that you would not want to enter late fees as miscellaneous income. They are member contributions, not income. You aren't taxed when you receive member contributions. You are taxed when you receive income.

If you'd like to keep track of these amounts separately, you could add a dummy account on the Accounting>Accounts page and enter the late payment fee deposits into it. Then, the transaction list for that account would only be tracking these fees. The problem with this approach is that it makes balancing your actual financial accounts more difficult since you are now tracking transactions for one account in two different places. It is up to you whether it would be worth your time to do this to be able to produce the type of report you are asking for.

I do have to say that most people will tell you that late fees do not help much to correct the issue you may be trying to address with them. If a member is not engaged enough to contribute regularly and within the guidelines your club has established, they may just not want to participate in an investment club at the moment. The problem might be better addressed in a different way. Plus, if you did so, you'd also get around having to produce a special report and your life as treasurer would be a little simpler.

Just a suggestion.

--
Laurie Frederiksen
Invest with your friends!
www.bivio.com

Become our Facebook friend! www.facebook.com/bivio
Follow us on twitter! www.twitter.com/bivio
Kevin Valade wrote:
> Thank you, I ran the reports and it does group a few
> together, but I basically had to go through and add them all
> up. Is there a different heading I could list the fees under
> so they show up on Bivio? Like Misc Income, I assume we
> could then be taxed on this.
>

Kevin:

I am going to assume you have read and understand Ira's
response to your initial question in which he explained the
mechanics of recording member's payments as "fees" and the
mechanics of recording expenses. In summary, fees take money
from one member, increase the cash balance in the account in
which the payment is deposited, and increase the value of
the other member's interest in the assets of the
partnership.

If you understand the mechanics of fees and expenses, then I
have to ask "Why do you need to account for the total fees
received over extended time periods?" The reason bivio
doesn't have a canned report to produce the information you
seek I believe is that most treasurer's would never need to
know or use that information, particularly in determining
the operating expenses of the partnership. Expenses will
have to be paid even if no member ever incurred a fee.

Your initial question made it sound like you somehow are
linking the amount of money the club has available to spend
on expenses with the amount of fees received. There doesn't
have to (some might say shouldn't) be any link between the
two.

Every club has pretty standard annual operating expenses;
e.g. bivio subscription, Better Investing Dues, maybe rent
for a meeting room, and a few bucks for stamps and
photocopies. The payment of these expenses is not linked
directly to a source of income or member payments; they are
just a reduction in the assets of the partnership.
Therefore, there is no need to know the amount of fees
received in order to budget for expenses.

In any case, you need to enter fees received as "fees."
Entering them as "misc income" will cause several problems
besides having members pay tax on non-taxable funds.

Jack Ranby, Treasurer
Grants Partners Invesment Club
If you enter them as misc income, you WILL be taxed on them. They are NOT income and should not be taxed when received.
 
Ira Smilovitz
Join me at InvestEd 2011
Investor Education at Its BestTM
San Diego, CA May 13-15, 2011
http://www.investor-education2011.org/
 
 
In a message dated 02/27/11 14:56:40 Eastern Standard Time, kade4111@bivio.com writes:
Thank you, I ran the reports and it does group a few
together, but I basically had to go through and add them all
up. Is there a different heading I could list the fees under
so they show up on Bivio? Like Misc Income, I assume we
could then be taxed on this.