Communications
club_cafe
HelpRegister
exiting member
We have one member who wants to leave our club on Dec. 31,
2006. Instead of selling off stock, we would like to buy
her out and divide her percentage among some or all of the
members. How do we do this?
You don't have those other members 'buy' her out. What you do is have those members contribute extra funds in the amount of the withdrawal payment due, and then process a withdrawal for that partner. The contributions for those extra funds should be processed as payments from those members.
 
You might be better off, transferring appreciated stock to the withdrawing member, and then having the other members contribute extra funds which can be used by the club to replentish the stock used in the payoff, or in any other way the club decides. That is the best way to defer taxable income for the remaining members. Check out the following trez-talk posts:
 
Our investment club just trys to maintain a cash surplus in
our bank account to pay off any member as they need some of
their money or all of it. We set aside about 15% each
quarter for this prupose. So far it has worked very well for
the Sanke River Investment Club.

Scott

Rip West wrote:
> You don't have those other members 'buy' her out. What you
> do is have those members contribute extra funds in the amount of the withdrawal
> payment due, and then process a withdrawal for that partner. The contributions
> for those extra funds should be processed as payments from those
> members.
>  
> You might be better off, transferring appreciated stock to
> the withdrawing member, and then having the other members contribute extra funds
> which can be used by the club to replentish the stock used in the payoff, or in
> any other way the club decides. That is the best way to defer taxable income for
> the remaining members. Check out the following trez-talk posts:
>  
>
> http://www.bivio.com/trez_talk/mail-msg?t=17312400003&s=2
>  
> http://www.bivio.com/trez_talk/mail-msg?t=2984700003
>  
> http://www.bivio.com/trez_talk/mail-msg?t=4241800003&s=1
>  
> Rip West
> Saint Paul,
> MN
Hi Scott,
 
<<
Our investment club just trys to maintain a cash surplus in our bank account to pay off any member as they need some of their money or all of it. We set aside about 15% each quarter for this prupose. So far it has worked very well for the Sanke River Investment Club.
>>
 
To each his own, but I can't endorse your club's practice. I think, over the years, that performance will really suffer if you are only 85% invested. And there is really no need for such a reserve, if you utilize appreciated stocks to pay members. This method yields better tax results, allows you to be fully invested at all times, and even gives better results for the departing members.
 
I again would urge people studying this problem to look at the following trez-talk articles on the bivio site.
 
Rip West
Saint Paul, MN