Communications
club_cafe
HelpRegister
Arizona Requirement to File Ptrshp Return Electronically; Waiver Request
This message is directed to members of clubs based in
Arizona.

Starting this year, the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR)
requires partnership returns to be filed electronically
unless the ADOR director grants a waiver. The waiver request
form (number 292) can be found on the ADOR website under the
"Forms" box. I suggest the treasurer submit the waiver
request as soon as possible so the waiver can be received
before the filing deadline.

Without the waiver, investment clubs will need to hire a
third-party tax professional with ADOR-approved software to
submit the return. ADOR is receiving reports that the cost
from AZ-based tax preparers may be at least $750. There is a
link through bivio for this service for a cheaper rate.
https://www.bivio.com/hn/State_Tax_Returns.html

Personally, I don't believe non-commercial partnerships like
investment clubs should have to pay a third-party to file
the AZ form 165. The only information we fill out on the
form is contact and identifying information. None of the
accounting numbers related to revenue or expenses is
transferred from the federal return that is filed with it.
There are no tax computations. Filling in the form 165 is
purely a clerical exercise that for our seven members I can
do quite easily.

I have asked the Arizona Chapter of BI if it would be
willing to coordinate with the Arizona-based clubs to mount
an effort to make the waiver process permanent until such
time as ADOR provides a means to enter this data directly
through its website without the need for 3rd party software.
I urge other members of Arizona-based clubs to communicate
your support for this effort to the officers of the Arizona
chapter. The email is: president@Arizona.betterinvesting.net
ADOR may be liberal with the waivers initially, but I fear
in a few years the waivers will not be given as freely. Now
is the time to push for a permanent solution.

I solicit information from treasurers of Arizona-based clubs
to learn how many clubs there are in Arizona and how many
members each has. A permanent solution will require
legislative action so the more information about the impact
of waiver requests on ADOR workload and the impact the
denial of a waiver will have on members of an investment
clubs the better. This information can be shared with me
privately at ranby at outlook dot com.

Jack Ranby, Treasurer
Grants Partners Investment Club
Jack,

While I can provide e-file services to AZ clubs at a reasonable rate through Glenwood Tax Services, I fully support your efforts to get relief directly from your state's Department of Revenue and/or legislature. More and more states are imposing e-file requirements in the mistaken belief that all entities are "large" enough to require professional support services. If you can't get direct waiver relief, another endpoint you might want to pursue is for the state to create a webfile portal where the return can be completed on the ADOR website. Here in NJ, we have such a facility.

I wish you the best in your efforts.

Ira Smilovitz, EA
Glenwood Tax Services

On Wed, Jan 20, 2021 at 3:49 PM John W Ranby Trustee PGM Cariboo Trust via bivio.com <user*15792700001@bivio.com> wrote:
This message is directed to members of clubs based in
Arizona.

Starting this year, the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR)
requires partnership returns to be filed electronically
unless the ADOR director grants a waiver. The waiver request
form (number 292) can be found on the ADOR website under the
"Forms" box. I suggest the treasurer submit the waiver
request as soon as possible so the waiver can be received
before the filing deadline.

Without the waiver, investment clubs will need to hire a
third-party tax professional with ADOR-approved software to
submit the return. ADOR is receiving reports that the cost
from AZ-based tax preparers may be at least $750. There is a
link through bivio for this service for a cheaper rate.
https://www.bivio.com/hn/State_Tax_Returns.html

Personally, I don't believe non-commercial partnerships like
investment clubs should have to pay a third-party to file
the AZ form 165. The only information we fill out on the
form is contact and identifying information. None of the
accounting numbers related to revenue or expenses is
transferred from the federal return that is filed with it.
There are no tax computations. Filling in the form 165 is
purely a clerical exercise that for our seven members I can
do quite easily.

I have asked the Arizona Chapter of BI if it would be
willing to coordinate with the Arizona-based clubs to mount
an effort to make the waiver process permanent until such
time as ADOR provides a means to enter this data directly
through its website without the need for 3rd party software.
I urge other members of Arizona-based clubs to communicate
your support for this effort to the officers of the Arizona
chapter. The email is: president@Arizona.betterinvesting.net
ADOR may be liberal with the waivers initially, but I fear
in a few years the waivers will not be given as freely. Now
is the time to push for a permanent solution.

I solicit information from treasurers of Arizona-based clubs
to learn how many clubs there are in Arizona and how many
members each has. A permanent solution will require
legislative action so the more information about the impact
of waiver requests on ADOR workload and the impact the
denial of a waiver will have on members of an investment
clubs the better. This information can be shared with me
privately at ranby at outlook dot com.

Jack Ranby, Treasurer
Grants Partners Investment Club
After a review of the legislation that mandated electronic
filing of partnership returns, I noticed the following: 1)
waivers may be granted for one year and renewed the
following year, with no indication that waivers will be
available after the second year; 2) waivers ARE NOT REQUIRED
under certain circumstances, including when either the IRS
or the Arizona Department of Revenue (AZDOR) has informed
the partnership that it will not be required to file
electronically. Therefore, if each investment club
(partnership) can obtain a letter from AZDOR stating that
the club is not required to file electronically, then the
club may file paper returns, perhaps indefinitely. Of
course, it would certainly be better if the legislature
could be persuaded to modify the law (again), or if AZDOR
would provide some means by which a partnership could file
its returns electronically without requiring the
intervention of a third party. Either solution will probably
require a considerable amount of time to implement, so now
is the time to contact your legislators and AZDOR to make
your feelings known.

William Peterson
Former Arizona Chapter Director
AZDOR retiree
BetterInvesting non-club member
I am looking at Arizona Form 165 (instructions) page 1.
About half way down, in left column there is a note in
italics that states "NOTE: A partnership that has no
Arizona income, deductions or credits for taxable year
2020 is not required to file a partnership return for
that year". If the club meets these conditions does that
mean don't worry about the AZ return?
 
> On January 20, 2021 at 3:48 PM "John W Ranby Trustee PGM Cariboo Trust via bivio.com" <user*15792700001@bivio.com> wrote:
>
>
> This message is directed to members of clubs based in
> Arizona.
>
> Starting this year, the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR)
> requires partnership returns to be filed electronically
> unless the ADOR director grants a waiver. The waiver request
> form (number 292) can be found on the ADOR website under the
> "Forms" box. I suggest the treasurer submit the waiver
> request as soon as possible so the waiver can be received
> before the filing deadline.
>
> Without the waiver, investment clubs will need to hire a
> third-party tax professional with ADOR-approved software to
> submit the return. ADOR is receiving reports that the cost
> from AZ-based tax preparers may be at least $750. There is a
> link through bivio for this service for a cheaper rate.
> https://www.bivio.com/hn/State_Tax_Returns.html
>
> Personally, I don't believe non-commercial partnerships like
> investment clubs should have to pay a third-party to file
> the AZ form 165. The only information we fill out on the
> form is contact and identifying information. None of the
> accounting numbers related to revenue or expenses is
> transferred from the federal return that is filed with it.
> There are no tax computations. Filling in the form 165 is
> purely a clerical exercise that for our seven members I can
> do quite easily.
>
> I have asked the Arizona Chapter of BI if it would be
> willing to coordinate with the Arizona-based clubs to mount
> an effort to make the waiver process permanent until such
> time as ADOR provides a means to enter this data directly
> through its website without the need for 3rd party software.
> I urge other members of Arizona-based clubs to communicate
> your support for this effort to the officers of the Arizona
> chapter. The email is: president@Arizona.betterinvesting.net
> ADOR may be liberal with the waivers initially, but I fear
> in a few years the waivers will not be given as freely. Now
> is the time to push for a permanent solution.
>
> I solicit information from treasurers of Arizona-based clubs
> to learn how many clubs there are in Arizona and how many
> members each has. A permanent solution will require
> legislative action so the more information about the impact
> of waiver requests on ADOR workload and the impact the
> denial of a waiver will have on members of an investment
> clubs the better. This information can be shared with me
> privately at ranby at outlook dot com.
>
> Jack Ranby, Treasurer
> Grants Partners Investment Club
Technically, yes. Did your club not have any dividends, interest, or capital gains? How did you get your bivio subscription? Any of these items require an AZ return. Besides that, the IRS shares information with the state tax agencies. If you file a federal return, the state tax authority (ADOR) will be looking for a tax return.

Ira Smilovitz, EA


On Wed, Jan 20, 2021 at 9:24 PM gmoots2 gmoots2 via bivio.com <user*20783200001@bivio.com> wrote:
I am looking at Arizona Form 165 (instructions) page 1.
About half way down, in left column there is a note in
italics that states "NOTE: A partnership that has no
Arizona income, deductions or credits for taxable year
2020 is not required to file a partnership return for
that year". If the club meets these conditions does that
mean don't worry about the AZ return?

> On January 20, 2021 at 3:48 PM "John W Ranby Trustee PGM Cariboo Trust via bivio.com" <user*15792700001@bivio.com> wrote:
>
>
> This message is directed to members of clubs based in
> Arizona.
>
> Starting this year, the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR)
> requires partnership returns to be filed electronically
> unless the ADOR director grants a waiver. The waiver request
> form (number 292) can be found on the ADOR website under the
> "Forms" box. I suggest the treasurer submit the waiver
> request as soon as possible so the waiver can be received
> before the filing deadline.
>
> Without the waiver, investment clubs will need to hire a
> third-party tax professional with ADOR-approved software to
> submit the return. ADOR is receiving reports that the cost
> from AZ-based tax preparers may be at least $750. There is a
> link through bivio for this service for a cheaper rate.
> https://www.bivio.com/hn/State_Tax_Returns.html
>
> Personally, I don't believe non-commercial partnerships like
> investment clubs should have to pay a third-party to file
> the AZ form 165. The only information we fill out on the
> form is contact and identifying information. None of the
> accounting numbers related to revenue or expenses is
> transferred from the federal return that is filed with it.
> There are no tax computations. Filling in the form 165 is
> purely a clerical exercise that for our seven members I can
> do quite easily.
>
> I have asked the Arizona Chapter of BI if it would be
> willing to coordinate with the Arizona-based clubs to mount
> an effort to make the waiver process permanent until such
> time as ADOR provides a means to enter this data directly
> through its website without the need for 3rd party software.
> I urge other members of Arizona-based clubs to communicate
> your support for this effort to the officers of the Arizona
> chapter. The email is: president@Arizona.betterinvesting.net
> ADOR may be liberal with the waivers initially, but I fear
> in a few years the waivers will not be given as freely. Now
> is the time to push for a permanent solution.
>
> I solicit information from treasurers of Arizona-based clubs
> to learn how many clubs there are in Arizona and how many
> members each has. A permanent solution will require
> legislative action so the more information about the impact
> of waiver requests on ADOR workload and the impact the
> denial of a waiver will have on members of an investment
> clubs the better. This information can be shared with me
> privately at ranby at outlook dot com.
>
> Jack Ranby, Treasurer
> Grants Partners Investment Club

It occurs to me that if you are going to pursue a change in law with your state that you just pursue a law allowing investment clubs to opt out of filing any AZ state partnership tax forms completely.

It is doubtful that there is any information on them that is not on the members Federal K-1 form and therefore will be taxed appropriately on any member personal state taxes.

North Carolina provides a nice example of this:

"A partnership whose only activity is as an investment partnership is not considered to be "doing business in North Carolina" and is not required to file a return in North Carolina or pay income tax to North Carolina on behalf of its nonresident partners. (For more information on
investment partnerships see 17 North Carolina Administrative
Code 06B .3503.)"

Laurie Frederiksen
Invest with your friends!
www.bivio.com

Become our Facebook friend! www.facebook.com/bivio
Follow us on twitter! www.twitter.com/bivio
Follow Us on Google+

Click here to Subscribe to the Club Cafe email list. Click here to Unsubscribe


On Wed, Jan 20, 2021 at 10:35 PM ira smilovitz via bivio.com <user*2883400001@bivio.com> wrote:
Technically, yes. Did your club not have any dividends, interest, or capital gains? How did you get your bivio subscription? Any of these items require an AZ return. Besides that, the IRS shares information with the state tax agencies. If you file a federal return, the state tax authority (ADOR) will be looking for a tax return.

Ira Smilovitz, EA


On Wed, Jan 20, 2021 at 9:24 PM gmoots2 gmoots2 via bivio.com <user*20783200001@bivio.com> wrote:
I am looking at Arizona Form 165 (instructions) page 1.
About half way down, in left column there is a note in
italics that states "NOTE: A partnership that has no
Arizona income, deductions or credits for taxable year
2020 is not required to file a partnership return for
that year". If the club meets these conditions does that
mean don't worry about the AZ return?

> On January 20, 2021 at 3:48 PM "John W Ranby Trustee PGM Cariboo Trust via bivio.com" <user*15792700001@bivio.com> wrote:
>
>
> This message is directed to members of clubs based in
> Arizona.
>
> Starting this year, the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR)
> requires partnership returns to be filed electronically
> unless the ADOR director grants a waiver. The waiver request
> form (number 292) can be found on the ADOR website under the
> "Forms" box. I suggest the treasurer submit the waiver
> request as soon as possible so the waiver can be received
> before the filing deadline.
>
> Without the waiver, investment clubs will need to hire a
> third-party tax professional with ADOR-approved software to
> submit the return. ADOR is receiving reports that the cost
> from AZ-based tax preparers may be at least $750. There is a
> link through bivio for this service for a cheaper rate.
> https://www.bivio.com/hn/State_Tax_Returns.html
>
> Personally, I don't believe non-commercial partnerships like
> investment clubs should have to pay a third-party to file
> the AZ form 165. The only information we fill out on the
> form is contact and identifying information. None of the
> accounting numbers related to revenue or expenses is
> transferred from the federal return that is filed with it.
> There are no tax computations. Filling in the form 165 is
> purely a clerical exercise that for our seven members I can
> do quite easily.
>
> I have asked the Arizona Chapter of BI if it would be
> willing to coordinate with the Arizona-based clubs to mount
> an effort to make the waiver process permanent until such
> time as ADOR provides a means to enter this data directly
> through its website without the need for 3rd party software.
> I urge other members of Arizona-based clubs to communicate
> your support for this effort to the officers of the Arizona
> chapter. The email is: president@Arizona.betterinvesting.net
> ADOR may be liberal with the waivers initially, but I fear
> in a few years the waivers will not be given as freely. Now
> is the time to push for a permanent solution.
>
> I solicit information from treasurers of Arizona-based clubs
> to learn how many clubs there are in Arizona and how many
> members each has. A permanent solution will require
> legislative action so the more information about the impact
> of waiver requests on ADOR workload and the impact the
> denial of a waiver will have on members of an investment
> clubs the better. This information can be shared with me
> privately at ranby at outlook dot com.
>
> Jack Ranby, Treasurer
> Grants Partners Investment Club
Hi, I am trying to figure this Arizona thing out. We do have one member living in Arizona now so do I go through all our stocks in the club and see if any are headquartered in Arizona if so that stock would have us file Arizona state tax? If no stocks in Arizona but one member lives there will I still need to file Arizona state tax? Thanks for your help! Mary Fine treasurer
On 01/20/2021 9:34 PM ira smilovitz via bivio.com <user*2883400001@bivio.com> wrote:
 
 
Technically, yes. Did your club not have any dividends, interest, or capital gains? How did you get your bivio subscription? Any of these items require an AZ return. Besides that, the IRS shares information with the state tax agencies. If you file a federal return, the state tax authority (ADOR) will be looking for a tax return.
 
Ira Smilovitz, EA
 

On Wed, Jan 20, 2021 at 9:24 PM gmoots2 gmoots2 via bivio.com <user* 20783200001@bivio.com> wrote:
I am looking at Arizona Form 165 (instructions) page 1. 
About half way down, in left column there is a note in
italics that states "NOTE:  A partnership that has no
Arizona income, deductions or credits for taxable year
2020 is not required to file a partnership return for
that year".  If the club meets these conditions does that
mean don't worry about the AZ return? 

> On January 20, 2021 at 3:48 PM "John W Ranby Trustee PGM Cariboo Trust via bivio.com" <user* 15792700001@bivio.com> wrote:
>
>
> This message is directed to members of clubs based in
> Arizona.
>
> Starting this year, the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR)
> requires partnership returns to be filed electronically
> unless the ADOR director grants a waiver. The waiver request
> form (number 292) can be found on the ADOR website under the
> "Forms" box. I suggest the treasurer submit the waiver
> request as soon as possible so the waiver can be received
> before the filing deadline.
>
> Without the waiver, investment clubs will need to hire a
> third-party tax professional with ADOR-approved software to
> submit the return. ADOR is receiving reports that the cost
> from AZ-based tax preparers may be at least $750. There is a
> link through bivio for this service for a cheaper rate.
> https://www.bivio.com/hn/State_Tax_Returns.html
>
> Personally, I don't believe non-commercial partnerships like
> investment clubs should have to pay a third-party to file
> the AZ form 165. The only information we fill out on the
> form is contact and identifying information. None of the
> accounting numbers related to revenue or expenses is
> transferred from the federal return that is filed with it.
> There are no tax computations.  Filling in the form 165 is
> purely a clerical exercise that for our seven members I can
> do quite easily.
>
> I have asked the Arizona Chapter of BI if it would be
> willing to coordinate with the Arizona-based clubs to mount
> an effort to make the waiver process permanent until such
> time as ADOR provides a means to enter this data directly
> through its website without the need for 3rd party software.
> I urge other members of Arizona-based clubs to communicate
> your support for this effort to the officers of the Arizona
> chapter. The email is: president@Arizona.betterinvesting.net
> ADOR may be liberal with the waivers initially, but I fear
> in a few years the waivers will not be given as freely. Now
> is the time to push for a permanent solution.
>
> I solicit information from treasurers of Arizona-based clubs
> to learn how many clubs there are in Arizona and how many
> members each has. A permanent solution will require
> legislative action so the more information about the impact
> of waiver requests on ADOR workload and the impact the
> denial of a waiver will have on members of an investment
> clubs the better. This information can be shared with me
> privately at ranby at outlook dot com.
>
> Jack Ranby, Treasurer
> Grants Partners Investment Club
Hi, I am trying to figure this Arizona thing out. We do have
one member living in Arizona now so do I go through all our
stocks in the club and see if any are headquartered in
Arizona if so that stock would have us file Arizona state
tax? If no stocks in Arizona but one member lives there will
I still need to file Arizona state tax? Thanks for your
help! Mary Fine treasurer

Mary: Based on the facts you present, you do NOT need to
file an Arizona Partnership return. It is the domicile of
the partnership (under the laws of what state was it
created) that governs whether it needs to file in Arizona.
So only if your partnership was organized under Arizona law
do you need to file in AZ. Neither the ownership of shares
of AZ-based companies nor partners living in AZ triggers a
filing requirement.
Jack Ranby
Thank You!!! Mary
> On 01/22/2021 6:04 PM John W Ranby Trustee PGM Cariboo Trust via bivio.com <user*15792700001@bivio.com> wrote:
>
>
> Hi, I am trying to figure this Arizona thing out. We do have
> one member living in Arizona now so do I go through all our
> stocks in the club and see if any are headquartered in
> Arizona if so that stock would have us file Arizona state
> tax? If no stocks in Arizona but one member lives there will
> I still need to file Arizona state tax? Thanks for your
> help! Mary Fine treasurer
>
> Mary: Based on the facts you present, you do NOT need to
> file an Arizona Partnership return. It is the domicile of
> the partnership (under the laws of what state was it
> created) that governs whether it needs to file in Arizona.
> So only if your partnership was organized under Arizona law
> do you need to file in AZ. Neither the ownership of shares
> of AZ-based companies nor partners living in AZ triggers a
> filing requirement.
> Jack Ranby